BioNLP'09 Shared Task on
Event Extraction
in conjunction with BioNLP, a NAACL-HLT 2009 workshop, June 4-5 2009, Boulder, Colorado
[Shared Task Home] [Evaluation Methods] [Master Result Table] [Team Profiles] [System Profiles]

Final Evaluation Results
of University of Tokyo, Tsujii lab

Task 1

Strict Matching

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     Event Class          gold (match)   answer (match)   recall    prec.   fscore
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     Localization          174 (   54)       59 (   54)    31.03    91.53    46.35
        Binding            347 (  112)      253 (  112)    32.28    44.27    37.33
    Gene_expression        722 (  361)      512 (  361)    50.00    70.51    58.51
     Transcription         137 (   44)      110 (   44)    32.12    40.00    35.63
  Protein_catabolism        14 (    4)        5 (    4)    28.57    80.00    42.11
    Phosphorylation        135 (   58)       73 (   58)    42.96    79.45    55.77
    ==[EVT-TOTAL]==       1529 (  633)     1012 (  633)    41.40    62.55    49.82
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      Regulation           291 (   31)       81 (   31)    10.65    38.27    16.67
  Positive_regulation      983 (  159)      527 (  159)    16.17    30.17    21.06
  Negative_regulation      379 (   23)       90 (   23)     6.07    25.56     9.81
    ==[REG-TOTAL]==       1653 (  213)      698 (  213)    12.89    30.52    18.12
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ==[ALL-TOTAL]==       3182 (  846)     1710 (  846)    26.59    49.47    34.59
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Approximate Span Matching

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     Event Class          gold (match)   answer (match)   recall    prec.   fscore
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     Localization          174 (   55)       58 (   55)    31.61    94.83    47.41
        Binding            347 (  120)      237 (  120)    34.58    50.63    41.10
    Gene_expression        722 (  372)      509 (  372)    51.52    73.08    60.44
     Transcription         137 (   49)      104 (   49)    35.77    47.12    40.66
  Protein_catabolism        14 (    4)        5 (    4)    28.57    80.00    42.11
    Phosphorylation        135 (   60)       72 (   60)    44.44    83.33    57.97
    ==[EVT-TOTAL]==       1529 (  660)      985 (  660)    43.17    67.01    52.51
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      Regulation           291 (   33)       78 (   33)    11.34    42.31    17.89
  Positive_regulation      983 (  175)      518 (  175)    17.80    33.78    23.32
  Negative_regulation      379 (   25)       90 (   25)     6.60    27.78    10.66
    ==[REG-TOTAL]==       1653 (  233)      686 (  233)    14.10    33.97    19.92
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ==[ALL-TOTAL]==       3182 (  893)     1671 (  893)    28.06    53.44    36.80
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Approximate Span Matching/Approximate Recursive Matching

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     Event Class          gold (match)   answer (match)   recall    prec.   fscore
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     Localization          174 (   55)       58 (   55)    31.61    94.83    47.41
        Binding            347 (  120)      237 (  120)    34.58    50.63    41.10
    Gene_expression        722 (  372)      509 (  372)    51.52    73.08    60.44
     Transcription         137 (   49)      104 (   49)    35.77    47.12    40.66
  Protein_catabolism        14 (    4)        5 (    4)    28.57    80.00    42.11
    Phosphorylation        135 (   60)       72 (   60)    44.44    83.33    57.97
    ==[EVT-TOTAL]==       1529 (  660)      985 (  660)    43.17    67.01    52.51
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      Regulation           291 (   33)       78 (   33)    11.34    42.31    17.89
  Positive_regulation      983 (  177)      518 (  177)    18.01    34.17    23.58
  Negative_regulation      379 (   25)       90 (   25)     6.60    27.78    10.66
    ==[REG-TOTAL]==       1653 (  235)      686 (  235)    14.22    34.26    20.09
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ==[ALL-TOTAL]==       3182 (  895)     1671 (  895)    28.13    53.56    36.88
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Event Decomposition/Approximate Recursive Matching

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     Event Class          gold (match)   answer (match)   recall    prec.   fscore
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     Localization          174 (   54)       59 (   54)    31.03    91.53    46.35
        Binding            398 (  172)      328 (  172)    43.22    52.44    47.38
    Gene_expression        722 (  361)      512 (  361)    50.00    70.51    58.51
     Transcription         137 (   44)      110 (   44)    32.12    40.00    35.63
  Protein_catabolism        14 (    4)        5 (    4)    28.57    80.00    42.11
    Phosphorylation        135 (   58)       73 (   58)    42.96    79.45    55.77
    ==[EVT-TOTAL]==       1580 (  693)     1087 (  693)    43.86    63.75    51.97
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      Regulation           338 (   38)       84 (   38)    11.24    45.24    18.01
  Positive_regulation     1186 (  223)      583 (  223)    18.80    38.25    25.21
  Negative_regulation      416 (   27)       90 (   27)     6.49    30.00    10.67
    ==[REG-TOTAL]==       1940 (  288)      757 (  288)    14.85    38.04    21.36
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ==[ALL-TOTAL]==       3520 (  981)     1844 (  981)    27.87    53.20    36.58
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Event Decomposition/Approximate Span Matching/Approximate Recursive Matching

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     Event Class          gold (match)   answer (match)   recall    prec.   fscore
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     Localization          174 (   55)       58 (   55)    31.61    94.83    47.41
        Binding            398 (  187)      304 (  187)    46.98    61.51    53.28
    Gene_expression        722 (  372)      509 (  372)    51.52    73.08    60.44
     Transcription         137 (   49)      104 (   49)    35.77    47.12    40.66
  Protein_catabolism        14 (    4)        5 (    4)    28.57    80.00    42.11
    Phosphorylation        135 (   60)       72 (   60)    44.44    83.33    57.97
    ==[EVT-TOTAL]==       1580 (  727)     1052 (  727)    46.01    69.11    55.24
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      Regulation           338 (   40)       81 (   40)    11.83    49.38    19.09
  Positive_regulation     1186 (  243)      571 (  243)    20.49    42.56    27.66
  Negative_regulation      416 (   32)       89 (   32)     7.69    35.96    12.67
    ==[REG-TOTAL]==       1940 (  315)      741 (  315)    16.24    42.51    23.50
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ==[ALL-TOTAL]==       3520 ( 1042)     1793 ( 1042)    29.60    58.11    39.22
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Task 2

Strict Matching

N/A

Approximate Span Matching

N/A

Approximate Span Matching/Approximate Recursive Matching

N/A

Event Decomposition/Approximate Recursive Matching

N/A

Event Decomposition/Approximate Span Matching/Approximate Recursive Matching

N/A

Task 3

Strict Matching

N/A

Approximate Span Matching

N/A

Approximate Span Matching/Approximate Recursive Matching

N/A

Event Decomposition/Approximate Recursive Matching

N/A

Event Decomposition/Approximate Span Matching/Approximate Recursive Matching

N/A