BioNLP'09 Shared Task on
Event Extraction
in conjunction with BioNLP, a NAACL-HLT 2009 workshop, June 4-5 2009, Boulder, Colorado
[Shared Task Home] [Evaluation Methods] [Master Result Table] [Team Profiles] [System Profiles]

Final Evaluation Results
of Pathway and Interaction Knowledge Base

Task 1

Strict Matching

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     Event Class          gold (match)   answer (match)   recall    prec.   fscore
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     Localization          174 (   19)       23 (   19)    10.92    82.61    19.29
        Binding            347 (   25)       63 (   25)     7.20    39.68    12.20
    Gene_expression        722 (  220)      295 (  220)    30.47    74.58    43.26
     Transcription         137 (   15)       38 (   15)    10.95    39.47    17.14
  Protein_catabolism        14 (    4)        7 (    4)    28.57    57.14    38.10
    Phosphorylation        135 (   46)       53 (   46)    34.07    86.79    48.94
    ==[EVT-TOTAL]==       1529 (  329)      479 (  329)    21.52    68.68    32.77
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      Regulation           291 (    4)       15 (    4)     1.37    26.67     2.61
  Positive_regulation      983 (   11)       43 (   11)     1.12    25.58     2.14
  Negative_regulation      379 (    1)        1 (    1)     0.26   100.00     0.53
    ==[REG-TOTAL]==       1653 (   16)       59 (   16)     0.97    27.12     1.87
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ==[ALL-TOTAL]==       3182 (  345)      538 (  345)    10.84    64.13    18.55
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Approximate Span Matching

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     Event Class          gold (match)   answer (match)   recall    prec.   fscore
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     Localization          174 (   19)       23 (   19)    10.92    82.61    19.29
        Binding            347 (   25)       63 (   25)     7.20    39.68    12.20
    Gene_expression        722 (  225)      295 (  225)    31.16    76.27    44.25
     Transcription         137 (   19)       38 (   19)    13.87    50.00    21.71
  Protein_catabolism        14 (    4)        7 (    4)    28.57    57.14    38.10
    Phosphorylation        135 (   48)       53 (   48)    35.56    90.57    51.06
    ==[EVT-TOTAL]==       1529 (  340)      479 (  340)    22.24    70.98    33.86
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      Regulation           291 (    5)       15 (    5)     1.72    33.33     3.27
  Positive_regulation      983 (   12)       43 (   12)     1.22    27.91     2.34
  Negative_regulation      379 (    1)        1 (    1)     0.26   100.00     0.53
    ==[REG-TOTAL]==       1653 (   18)       59 (   18)     1.09    30.51     2.10
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ==[ALL-TOTAL]==       3182 (  358)      538 (  358)    11.25    66.54    19.25
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Approximate Span Matching/Approximate Recursive Matching

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     Event Class          gold (match)   answer (match)   recall    prec.   fscore
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     Localization          174 (   19)       23 (   19)    10.92    82.61    19.29
        Binding            347 (   25)       63 (   25)     7.20    39.68    12.20
    Gene_expression        722 (  225)      295 (  225)    31.16    76.27    44.25
     Transcription         137 (   19)       38 (   19)    13.87    50.00    21.71
  Protein_catabolism        14 (    4)        7 (    4)    28.57    57.14    38.10
    Phosphorylation        135 (   48)       53 (   48)    35.56    90.57    51.06
    ==[EVT-TOTAL]==       1529 (  340)      479 (  340)    22.24    70.98    33.86
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      Regulation           291 (    5)       15 (    5)     1.72    33.33     3.27
  Positive_regulation      983 (   12)       43 (   12)     1.22    27.91     2.34
  Negative_regulation      379 (    1)        1 (    1)     0.26   100.00     0.53
    ==[REG-TOTAL]==       1653 (   18)       59 (   18)     1.09    30.51     2.10
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ==[ALL-TOTAL]==       3182 (  358)      538 (  358)    11.25    66.54    19.25
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Event Decomposition/Approximate Recursive Matching

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     Event Class          gold (match)   answer (match)   recall    prec.   fscore
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     Localization          174 (   19)       23 (   19)    10.92    82.61    19.29
        Binding            398 (   49)       77 (   49)    12.31    63.64    20.63
    Gene_expression        722 (  220)      295 (  220)    30.47    74.58    43.26
     Transcription         137 (   15)       38 (   15)    10.95    39.47    17.14
  Protein_catabolism        14 (    4)        7 (    4)    28.57    57.14    38.10
    Phosphorylation        135 (   46)       53 (   46)    34.07    86.79    48.94
    ==[EVT-TOTAL]==       1580 (  353)      493 (  353)    22.34    71.60    34.06
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      Regulation           338 (    8)       15 (    8)     2.37    53.33     4.53
  Positive_regulation     1186 (   14)       43 (   14)     1.18    32.56     2.28
  Negative_regulation      416 (    1)        1 (    1)     0.24   100.00     0.48
    ==[REG-TOTAL]==       1940 (   23)       59 (   23)     1.19    38.98     2.30
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ==[ALL-TOTAL]==       3520 (  376)      552 (  376)    10.68    68.12    18.47
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Event Decomposition/Approximate Span Matching/Approximate Recursive Matching

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     Event Class          gold (match)   answer (match)   recall    prec.   fscore
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
     Localization          174 (   19)       23 (   19)    10.92    82.61    19.29
        Binding            398 (   50)       77 (   50)    12.56    64.94    21.05
    Gene_expression        722 (  225)      295 (  225)    31.16    76.27    44.25
     Transcription         137 (   19)       38 (   19)    13.87    50.00    21.71
  Protein_catabolism        14 (    4)        7 (    4)    28.57    57.14    38.10
    Phosphorylation        135 (   48)       53 (   48)    35.56    90.57    51.06
    ==[EVT-TOTAL]==       1580 (  365)      493 (  365)    23.10    74.04    35.21
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      Regulation           338 (    9)       15 (    9)     2.66    60.00     5.10
  Positive_regulation     1186 (   15)       43 (   15)     1.26    34.88     2.44
  Negative_regulation      416 (    1)        1 (    1)     0.24   100.00     0.48
    ==[REG-TOTAL]==       1940 (   25)       59 (   25)     1.29    42.37     2.50
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ==[ALL-TOTAL]==       3520 (  390)      552 (  390)    11.08    70.65    19.16
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Task 2

Strict Matching

N/A

Approximate Span Matching

N/A

Approximate Span Matching/Approximate Recursive Matching

N/A

Event Decomposition/Approximate Recursive Matching

N/A

Event Decomposition/Approximate Span Matching/Approximate Recursive Matching

N/A

Task 3

Strict Matching

N/A

Approximate Span Matching

N/A

Approximate Span Matching/Approximate Recursive Matching

N/A

Event Decomposition/Approximate Recursive Matching

N/A

Event Decomposition/Approximate Span Matching/Approximate Recursive Matching

N/A